Hen and HoundDr. Ishigaki is famous for his "one fly" approach to tenkara. My understanding of how that came about, though, is that the fly pattern he settled on was "as good as" rather than "better than" what he had been using before. That feeling was heightened while we fished together after the 2011 Summit. He has flies of different hackle color in his box and I asked him how he chose which to use. He said he just picked one. The color really didn't matter. And that suggests to me, at least, that the method should perhaps be called "any fly" rather than "one fly." To further test that theory, when I was in Colorado visiting my sister the following week I tied a few flies with the materials that were at hand: Ginger colored hackles from her hens and a bit of dubbing from her partner's yellow Labrador Retriever. Orange silk thread to hold it all together (that's what was already in the bobbin holder) and a barbless hook - required for Rocky Mountain National Park. I was hoping to fool a few brookies or cutthroats with them.
I really enjoyed fishing in Rocky Mountain National Park. The park is truly tenkara heaven. There are miles and miles of small streams, many of which seem to be chock full of hungry trout. Most of the fish I caught were in the 7-12" range, which is just about the size of fish for which tenkara was developed. My largest tenkara-caught trout to date was taken in one of the small streams in the park, though, which underscores my feeling that if the streams you fish contain large trout (and any stream that supports natural reproduction will probably have at least a few) eventually you'll catch one. I fished a number of different flies on that trip, but all seemed to work. Each of the fish in the following photos was caught on a different fly.
Clockwise from upper left: Greenback cutthroat, brookie, rainbow, brown I think I understand the arguments supporting the "one fly" philosophy, but I also understand the arguments supporting a variety of flies. For myself, I fish several different patterns, and probably will continue to do so. It's not so much a dismissal or rejection of the one fly approach. It is more that I like playing around with new flies too much to give it up. Whatever puts a smile on your face. That's the way to fish. I do like that Hen and Hound, though. The color stands out against dark water and a dark bottom, and it is more visible than a gray/grizzly fly when there are bubbles or foam lines. When fishing this fly I found I was able to watch the fly rather than the line much of the time. I don't now have ready access to ginger hens or a Labrador Retriever. For substitutes, I picked up an India Hen Cape that is only slightly darker. Instead of the Labrador Retriever dubbing, I'll settle for some Golden Retriever that I swapped some flies for a couple years ago in an attempt to make a reasonably accurate Tupps dubbing blend. The result will still be a Hen and Hound, and will still be a thrown-together fly made from what is available. And I'll bet it will still catch fish.
Return from Hen and Hound to Tenkara Flies Return from Hen and Hound to TenkaraBum Home |
Big Thompson Rainbow
