Finding All the Fishes

by Alan L
(Kansas City)

Red Shiner

Red Shiner

Red Shiner Goldeneye Common Shiner Walleye

I had a lot of fun with the Streamer Challenge last summer and fall. I want to thank Chris for organizing and officiating the contest.

First, I'm lucky to live in a pretty fishy area.The Missouri and Kansas rivers meet at Kansas City with a lot of small tributaries flowing down through the bluffs. The Ozarks are only a few hours away to the east and south. If someplace has water year round there are probably fish in it. I've found that everything from small suburban drainage creeks, to park ponds, flood impoundments, reservoirs, rivers and everything that connects them has fishing living it. Break each site down by the basic rules of fishing-- look for moving water, structure and holes.

For the Challenge I started with what I knew and made a list of species and where to find them. My local starting points were the lime stone creeks in the Kansas suburbs. They're beautiful, fairly clear and easily accessible by bike trials. Mill and Tomahawk creeks provided three species of sun fish, a Large mouth Bass,Creek Chubs, a Channel Cat and two different shiners. Indian creek produced a Black Buffalo, Shortnose Gar and numerous uncaught carp.

These were the usual suspects that are always available. To grow the list I started targeting specific places for specific species that I knew where there or should be. The James A. Reed Conservation Area had Redear Sunfish and crappie, the Rocky Ford Area out in kansas had wipers and a surprise Goldeye. A literal wide spot between two lanes of traffic had Golden Shiners washed down from a neighborhood pond.

My big local discovery (local= 1 hour drive) was the dam face at Hillsdale Reservoir, see "Another Shoreline". A fly club friend tipped me off and I caught numerous Freshwater Drum, a White Bass and a WALLEYE!

The local count ended up in the high teens. To move beyond that required road trips. I planned these around the trout parks and conservation areas I was familiar with in southwest Missouri. All these areas have rich ozark streams with lots of species (plus trout), but targeted planning is a must.

Many small species are drainage specific and it's necessary to identify the right watershed for the different fish. The best examples are Cardinal, Bleeding and Duskystripe Shiners. They are very similar but will never be found together. Cardinals are in the Shoal Creek drainage running west and then south to the Arkansas. A few miles to the east Dustkystripe Shiners are common in water draining south to the White River. Bleeding Shiners are widespread just to the north in the Osage drainage which flows north to the Missouri. Hornyhead Chubs in the Missouri drainage and Redspot Chubs in the Arkansas are nearly identical fish, the difference is where you catch them.

After the standard stuff species equals micros. Establishing a comfort level with tiny flies is a must. By the end of the contest I had developed a standard small fish setup for prospecting new water. Using White Killer Buggers I would work the entire area with a size 20 on either the Soyokaze27 or the Badger UNC. This would locate larger shiners as well as sunfish, chubs and small bass. When a school of normal size shiners was spotted I would switch to the Kurenai HM30R with a size 26 plus a #6 shot. This is a good all around shiner setup and will catch most fish down to about 2 1/2-- 3inches. For the smallest fish I used a size 30 fly with a #10 shot on the Kiyotaki 18 and a short line. This is close range sight fishing, placing the fly in front of the fish and anticipating the take.

Other than my micro rod collection my rod choices were very simple. I used the Diawa Kiyose 53M a lot. If the water was open the length was a plus, if the fish was big I had the power to land it. I used it for the Drum, Buffalo, Gar, Walleye, Smallmouth and two big trout. For flexibility on the in between fish and water the Suntech Keiryu Special GM39 took care of everything else. I tended to rig heavy--catch the fish, don't lose it. Since the Challenge finished the Zereosum has come back out.

While sticking to what I knew for most of the species I did make some nice trips to new water. A family wedding in Northern Michigan allowed me to spend a little time in the Betsie River for a common shiner as well as some rainbows and chubs. My favorite close new place was the National Tallgrass Prairie Preserve in the Flint Hills where I got some some new micros in tiny clear prairie streams.

The best unsuccessful fishing was while I was in Utah for the Oni School. I spent three hours on a extremely windy morning high in the Wasatch Mountains trying to catch Bonneville Cutthroats out of a tiny overgrown stream. I eventually caught two fish but I went through eleven flies and the streamers ran out at about number five.

The Streamer Challenge provided the focus and inspiration to review and revisit all the fish and places I've discovered in the last four years. Spring is here and it's time to get out the maps and satellite pictures to find the new water and new fish, but perhaps with lighter rigs and a more relaxed attitude.

Comments for Finding All the Fishes

Click here to add your own comments

Apr 03, 2017
Nice!
by: Jay Guarneri

The streamer challenge was a lot of fun! It's a great combination of working techniques and geography to your advantage, and you nailed it. I didn't realize you came out to Rocky Ford for your wiper; next time you come out this way give me a shout. I've figured out where you can pretty consistently hook in to the big ones, and I can also take you to my spot for spotted bass, one of the nicest tenkara streams in Kansas (at least that I've found).

Apr 03, 2017
Great Report
by: Les A.

Alan,
Your multiple fish adventure has inspired me to try to catch as many species as possible this year. My friend Troy at work and I have a contest going. So far, I am ahead 4 to zero! He hasn't gone fishing yet this year.

A great resource I found is your state chapter of the "American Fisheries Society." I found out from the Idaho chapter that there are close to 100 species of fish in Idaho, 39 are native species. I was surprised that there are so many.

I also found a great picture of the speckled dace, and have tied a minimal speckled dace based on Chris' minimal dace. It might be fun to have a "minimal" streamer contest. Following Chris' lead, I tied my minimal speckled dace with just a hook, speckled thread, and a natural bucktail.

Thanks again for your inspiration Alan! I would love to catch a Walleye on my fixed line setup! I am jealous having been raised in Minnesota. There are not too many places to fish for Walleye in Idaho.

Apr 04, 2017
Inspiring!
by: Terry Farmer

Great report. I've let other activities get in the way of my fishing lately. Your report has inspired me to get back after it! Thanks.

Apr 04, 2017
Species
by: Phillip

Very cool. It seems that the warmer water is very good for variety, even if the trout don't like it as much. I love catching new species.

This year I've caught eight different salmonids (three are different O. Clarkii ssps), and one pumpkinseed sunfish. I really want to find a bull this year, and hopefully catch a carp. We'll see.

Apr 04, 2017
Bull?
by: Les A.

Phillip,

What are you after, an Angus or Herford bull? LOL! What kind of fly do you tie for them! LOL For our eastern and southern brethren (sisters too) Bull trout are a member of the char family. They look a lot like Brook trout. In Idaho they are protected and you can't target them. However I seem to catch a fair share if they are present.

Last January, I caught one bull trout three times in one day. I know it was the same one because it looked like someone had used a hole punch on his tail. He was also in the same eddy. He had a perfectly round hole at the bottom of his tail.

Apr 05, 2017
Bull Trout
by: Phillip

Yeah, I'm looking to catch a bull trout this season. There's a specially-permitted catch and release season on the Flathead. I also saw my friend accidentally pull two small ones out of a hole that we were taking turns fishing.

The Centennial Valley around Butte was once the best bull trout fishery in the region. Before we poisoned everything, at least. They're making a comeback upstream of Anaconda, though. I tied up some big hookless streamers to ply the waters of Warm Springs and see if I can draw one out of hiding. I figure I don't have to actually catch one to appreciate it.

(I do remember reading an article on fly fishing for Cape buffalo. Bring your 20wt!)

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Your Tenkara Stories.





Walk softly and carry a long stick. - Teddy Roosevelt (almost)

Tenkara has no strict rules. Enjoy tenkara in your own way.
- Eiji Yamakawa

“The bitterness of poor quality remains long after the sweetness of low price is forgotten” – Benjamin Franklin


Warning:

The hooks are sharp.
The coffee's hot.
The fish are slippery when wet.


Currently processing orders that were received Oct 20.